This piece reads like a delicate and reflective sonnet. I like how you use the dried roses as a symbol of memory, love, and the passage of time, and the repetition of "it’s dead, it’s dead" gives it a luring emphasis.
Well written my friend!
I like the stream of consciousness type feel to it, and especially the repetition of lines like “It’s dead” and “In red”.
There are a few spelling or grammar ‘errors’ however. I put ‘errors’ in quotes because I don’t know if they are intentional, but I’ll write some here in case you want to know:
In “wander’s it’s soul”, “it’s bones”, and a few other times, there shouldn’t be an apostrophe in the word “it’s”. “It’s” with an apostrophe is used only as a contraction of “it is”, and “its” without an apostrophe is used for possessives, like in these quotes. So “it’s bones” reads as “it is bones”, for example. “Its” is the only possessive without an apostrophe.
“Wander’s” in “wander’s it’s soul” should probably be “wanders”. I assume you were going for the verb “wanders”, and I’m pretty sure verbs never have ‘s at the end, since they can’t own things.
You also mention a “fallen autumn leave”, but the singular of “leaves” is “leaf”, not “leave”. It’s weird, but that’s just how it is.
Okay, now that’s over with. I’m sorry if I seemed really negative, but I just wanted to provide some pointers to improve (if those things were unintentional). I do really like this poem, the rhythm really captivated me while I was reading it and I like the imagery, but most of the review ended up being grammar corrections. This isn’t because of your poem, it’s just because I can’t explain things in a very concise way.
Posted 7 Months Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
This comment has been deleted by the poster.
7 Months Ago
Thank you so much for taking the time to read and leave such thoughtful feedback. I really appreciat.. read moreThank you so much for taking the time to read and leave such thoughtful feedback. I really appreciate your attention to detail — especially with the grammar corrections. You’re absolutely right about “its” vs. “it’s” and “wanders” — those were unintentional slip-ups on my part, English is not my first language and I’m glad that you pointed them out. The “leave” instead of “leaf” was just one of those weird typos that my eyes skipped over, but I totally get how that stood out.
And your message didn’t come off as negative.In fact, it’s super helpful and encouraging. I’m glad you liked the repetition and stream-of-consciousness style — that means a lot to me. Thanks again for the kind words and honest suggestions
This piece reads like a delicate and reflective sonnet. I like how you use the dried roses as a symbol of memory, love, and the passage of time, and the repetition of "it’s dead, it’s dead" gives it a luring emphasis.
Well written my friend!