Your writing is fine, but the differences between poetry for the page and song lyrics get in the way. As my daughter said, when I asked her why so many of her songs were what’s often called a Dismal Damsel poem, when they appear on the page, she said, “Why? Because angst sells, Dad.
And she’s right,…when it’s a song. But in this, as the reader views it, someone unknown is talking to someone not introduced, taking them to task for unspecified actions. Meaningful to those two, but because it’s written TO that person. It reads as if you sent a letter to someone and it was accidentally delivered to the reader, instead.
In general, on the page, the goal is to make the reader feel and care. We don’t say, “I cried at the funeral,” for example. Instead, we give the reader a reason to weep,
Another problem with lyrics is that often, the meaning isn’t as important as the impact of the performance, Certainly, the line from America's Tin Man, “Oz never did give nothing to the Tin Man, that he didn’t, didn’t already have.” makes sense, though it does state the obvious. But the next line goes off the rails with, “And cause never was the reason for the evening Or the tropic of Sir Galahad.
Yet because of the rhythm and melody, it works and became a hit…” As a song.
On the page, though, missing the music, vocal performance, and harmony…
I love to write poetry and then turn it into songs. I am a singer/songwriter for Weathered Pages, a Fort Worth, Texas based music charity. Check us out on Apple Music, Spotify, I Heart Radio, Pandora.. more..